The Ultimate Pizza Guide to America's Top 50 Pizzerias in the U.S.

Pizza isn’t just food—it’s a cultural phenomenon. From New York’s legendary foldable slices to Chicago’s deep-dish pies and the blistered crusts of Neapolitan pies, every region has its own take on this beloved dish.

At Rekklist, we’ve done the work for you. Using a data-driven approach, we’ve analyzed nearly 100 trusted sources—including food critics, customer reviews, industry awards, and expert rankings—to create the definitive list of the Top 50 Pizza Restaurants in America for 2025. Whether you’re on the hunt for a classic institution or an under-the-radar gem, this guide will help you find the most mouthwatering slices in the country.

🍽️ What Makes a Great Pizzeria?

✔️ Authentic Dough & Cooking Techniques – Whether it’s coal-fired, wood-fired, or Detroit-style pan pizza, the baking process and dough fermentation are crucial to flavor and texture.

✔️ High-Quality Ingredients – The best pizzerias source San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, high-protein flour, and house-made toppings.

✔️ Consistency & Legacy – Iconic pizza shops have perfected their recipes over decades and maintained a loyal following.

✔️ Expert Craftsmanship – True pizzaiolos train for years to master the art of dough stretching, fermentation, and oven techniques

🔗 Join the Pizza Conversation!

🍕 Have you visited any of these legendary pizzerias? Share your experience by tagging us on Instagram @rekklist and using #Top50Pizza for a chance to be featured.

📍 Looking for the best pizza near you? Use our interactive map to find top-rated pizzerias in your city.

✅ Follow Rekklist for up-to-the-minute rankings & foodie insights!

Read More